10 Best Mattresses Our Experts Reviewed in 2024

Feb 01, 2024
Fact Checked
Our Reviews Team researched, tested, and ranked the best mattresses of 2024. The Helix Midnight Luxe is our top recommendation based on extensive in-person testing and analysis. Read on to see which mattresses made our top 10.
Written by: Marten Carlson
Medical Reviewer: Raj Dasgupta, MD
  • After reviewing hundreds of mattresses, our Reviews Team chose the Helix Midnight Luxe as the best overall, due to its balanced cushioning, airflow, lumbar support, and pressure relief.
  • Our recommendations for the best mattresses of 2024 include options for different sleep preferences and positions.
  • Our expert take includes feedback from hands-on testing and analysis.
  • When purchasing a new mattress, the top factors to consider include the type of sleeper you are (side, back, stomach, or combination sleeper), if you are seeking pain relief, your budget, mattress materials and firmness, whether a trial period is included, and the warranty conditions.

Our Reviews Team researched hundreds of mattress models and mystery shopped more than 30 mattress brands in person and online. Here’s how we made our selections:

  • Analyzed costs, benefits, features, and brand policies, such as returns and trial periods
  • Consulted sleep specialists, including doctors, occupational therapists, and physical therapists for insight on choosing the best mattresses
  • Identified and tested key factors for an objective measure of features, like motion transfer, pressure relief, edge support, and cooling technologies
  • Compiled customer reviews from verified customers on trusted third-party sites, including the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Trustpilot

We’ve personally rested on and tested each mattress against these factors for an unbiased assessment. Our selections were also medically reviewed to ensure each brand and model is appropriate for the needs of our readers.

Many factors contribute to a good night’s sleep. In addition to a healthy lifestyle and sleep environment, a supportive and comfortable mattress is high on the list. While opinions about comfort can vary greatly from one person to the other, the best mattresses are designed to accommodate different body types and sleep styles while still offering great value.

To help you find the best bed for you, we tested hundreds of mattresses in our sleep lab and scored them in more than a dozen performance categories. In this review, we share the costs, specifications, pros and cons, customer reviews, and our expert take on the 10 best mattresses of 2024 based on our extensive, in-person testing.

The best mattresses in 2024


Compare the best mattresses of 2024, as of February 2024

Queen cost before discounts $2,373.80 $1,499 $1,995 $1,199 $1,799 $2,499 $1,332 $2,373.80 $4,495
Firmness Medium-firm Medium-firm Plush soft, luxury firm, firm Medium-Firm Softer, luxury firm, firmer, plus Plush, luxury firm, firm Soft, medium, firm Medium-firm Adjustable
Mattress type Hybrid Hybrid Hybrid Hybrid Innerspring Hybrid Hybrid Hybrid Air chamber
White glove delivery No Yes Yes Yes No Yes
only through the third-party partner Load Up
No No Yes

Best mattresses of 2024, reviewed by experts

Best Hybrid: Helix Midnight Luxe

Best Overall
9.3 Excellent
Discount: Get 20% off sitewide plus two free dream pillows with a mattress purchase
9.3 Excellent
Features
  • Price: $1,373.80–$2,873.80
  • Material: Hybrid
  • Firmness: Medium-firm
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Shipping: Free shipping
  • Warranty: 15 years
  • Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king
  • Mattress height: 13.5″
Pros & Cons
Pros Comfortable pillow top that adds a plush feel Zoned lumbar support Designed to promote cooling and breathability Cons Lack of in-home delivery options Pricey investment
Additional Information

The Helix Midnight Luxe is a high-end hybrid mattress with a medium-firm feel. The mattress provides good cushioning without that “sinking in” feeling and offers excellent airflow, lumbar support, and pressure relief. That’s a combination that works well for all sleep positions.

Our expert take

The Helix Midnight Luxe is a hybrid mattress featuring four layers of foam, individually wrapped coils, and a pillow top made with plush, breathable fabric. It’s the brand’s most popular model and should accommodate a range of body types and sleep positions.

Lying on the Midnight Luxe, you’ll first notice that it has a super-comfy pillow top. This adds a plush feel to the top of the mattress, mimicking what you might experience in a nice hotel.

While Helix rates its firmness as medium, our Reviews Team thinks it’s a touch firmer—closer to a 6.5 out of 10. The mattress is made with zoned lumbar support, which means the coils beneath the shoulders and hips are softer, with reinforced coils along the perimeter and in the lumbar region. While the 14-inch Midnight Luxe has contouring memory foam in its construction, its transition layer and coils are responsive and adapt quickly to changes in pressure. That makes it easy to move around and change positions.

Helix mattresses come compressed and rolled into a box. It takes 30–45 minutes to expand to its full height. The company no longer offers an in-home delivery and mattress removal service.

Our recommendation

Who will love it

  • Combination sleepers will find it responds well to movement.
  • Hot sleepers may find the construction boosts breathability.
  • Solid lumbar and back support for people living with pain.

Who should avoid it

  • Those who are easily disturbed by a restless bed partner, due to the bouncy responsiveness.

  • Shoppers on a budget might want to look for less expensive options.

Customer reviews:

Across Trustpilot and the BBB, there are minimal reviews for the Helix Midnight Luxe mattress. On Trustpilot, the brand has a rating of 2.5 stars from six reviews, which doesn’t provide a good overall picture. On BBB, Helix is an accredited business with an A+ rating and 1.48 out of 5 stars from an average of 29 reviews. On Google, the mattress has 4.3 out of 5 stars with more than 22,000 reviews, providing a better view of the customer experience.

Customer service

You can reach Helix customer service by:

  • Phone: Call 831-777-5976, available Monday through Friday from 12 p.m. to 6 p.m. ET
  • Text: Texting HELIX to 67069, available Monday through Friday from 12 p.m. to 6 p.m. ET
  • Chat: Live chat via the bottom right corner of the website, available seven days a week from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. ET
  • Email: help@helixsleep.com
  • Submit a contact form on the website

Helix Luxe mattresses have a 15-year warranty and come with a 100-night trial period to make sure you enjoy the experience.

Payment options

Credit card payment options include Visa, MasterCard, American Express, and Discover. Other options include Shop Pay, Amazon Pay, PayPal, and Google Pay. Helix offers financing through Affirm and Katapult.

The company currently offers 30% off for military members, first responders, students, and teachers. The discount code can’t be combined with other promotional codes.

Our Top Pick

Best Value Mattress: Nectar Premier

Best Overall Memory Foam
9.1 Excellent
Discount: Up to 40% off mattresses
9.1 Excellent
Features
  • Price: $1,049–$2,398
  • Material: Hybrid
  • Firmness: Medium-firm
  • Trial period: 365 nights
  • Shipping: Free shipping
  • Warranty: Limited forever warranty
  • Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king, split king
  • Mattress height: 13″
Pros & Cons
Pros Cooling cover and gel-infused foam to combat heat retention Discounts available for certain occupations A generous 365-night trial period Cons Can take up to two days to fully expand Feels bouncy, which may not be for everyone Not many reviews available on third-party review sites
Additional Information

The Nectar Premier Hybrid has impressive comfort layers that can help alleviate pressure point pain, which makes it a good option for side and back sleepers. Due to a hybrid construction that includes innersprings, it has a responsive feel balanced by its contouring foam top layers.

Our expert’s take

The Nectar Premier Hybrid mattress is a hybrid mattress made of CertiPUR-US-certified foam layers, innersprings, and a quilted cooling cover to help regulate your temperature while sleeping. Compared to the other Nectar mattresses, the Premier mattress offers upgraded cooling and contouring with enhanced pressure relief and stable support for sleepers.

Memory foam tends to trap heat, making it difficult to fall asleep quickly. Research from 2023 recommends a sleeping temperature of 68–77 degrees Fahrenheit for older adults, so it’s important to remain on the cooler side while sleeping. [2]Baniassadi, Amir, et al. Science of the Total Environment. Nov. 15, 2023. Nighttime Ambient Temperature and Sleep in Community-Dwelling Older Adults. Found on the internet at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0048969723042468 The Nectar Premier Hybrid mattress has a cooling fabric cover and a layer of gel memory foam called ActiveCool HD, which Nectar says helps regulate the mattress’s temperature. The innerspring coils in this hybrid mattress also improve air flow to minimize heat retention.

Throughout our mattress testing, we noticed that most hybrid mattresses don’t isolate motion well. Because of the springy coils at the bottom, couples often complain about feeling their partner’s movements when they shift sleeping positions in the night. The good news is that the Nectar Premier Hybrid isn’t like most mattresses. This model contains three plush comfort layers that help eliminate motion transfer.

Nectar mattresses are shipped compressed and rolled into a box. You can’t sleep on the mattress until it’s fully expanded. Once unboxed, the mattress will expand to its full height, which takes one to two days. Nectar advises customers to unbox their mattress within 90 days of delivery, or it will be ineligible for warranty claims. Similar to Saatva, Nectar mattresses come with a 365-night trial period and lifetime warranty, called a Forever Warranty, that covers the entire time you own the Nectar mattress.

Our recommendation

Who will love it

  • Couples may appreciate the high motion isolation to avoid nighttime disruptions.
  • Hot sleepers may appreciate the cooling upgrades.
  • Side sleepers can benefit from the cushioning of the slow-moving foam.

Who should avoid it

  • Stomach sleepers might find it lacks sufficient hip support.
  • Combination sleepers who need a little more bounce to change positions comfortably will want to skip this mattress.

Customer reviews

Nectar reviews and ratings on Trustpilot and BBB are scarce. At the time we updated this article, Nectar had a rating of 1.5 out of 5 on Trustpilot with 116 reviews. On BBB, it’s an accredited business with an A+ rating, which means Nectar is responsive to customer complaints, and 2.83 out of 5 stars from an average of 447 customer reviews. On Amazon, it’s rated 4.3 out of 5 stars with more than 6,400 reviews.

Customer service

You can reach Nectar customer service by:

  • Phone: Call 888-863-2827, available seven days a week from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. PT
  • Email: support@nectarsleep.com
  • Chat: Live chat available seven days a week from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. PT

Returns within the 365-night trial window are free, but you can’t start a return request until 30 days after receiving your mattress. 

Nectar offers a Forever Warranty that will last for as long as you own the mattress.You can get a full mattress replacement for the first 10 years with an eligible warranty claim.

Payment options

Payment options for Nectar include American Express, MasterCard, Visa, Discover, PayPal, and Amazon Pay. Nectar offers financing through Affirm and Splitit and offers a lease-to-own option through Acima.

Military members, first responders, and health care professionals take note: you can get a 40% discount, but it can’t be combined with other offers. 

Best Affordable Luxury: Saatva Classic Mattress

Best Affordable Luxury
9.7 Exceptional
Discount: Save up to $350
9.7 Exceptional
Features
  • Price: $1,295–$2,372
  • Material: Hybrid
  • Firmness: Plush soft, luxury firm, firm
  • Trial period: 365 nights
  • Shipping: Free shipping, free in-home delivery and setup
  • Warranty: Limited lifetime warranty
  • Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king, split California king
  • Mattress height: 11.5″ (inches) or 14.5″
Pros & Cons
Pros Choice of three firmness levels Two mattress heights to choose from Made with eco-friendly materials 365-night trial period and lifetime limited warranty Cons $99 processing fee for returns Queen size weighs more than 100 pounds
Additional Information

The luxurious, organic Saatva mattress is especially useful if you’re looking for the comfort of a high-end innerspring mattress without the price tag to match. It’s available in three firmness options: plush soft, luxury firm, and firm. According to research, the Classic offers zoned firmness, which is particularly well-suited to back sleepers who need extra hip support and want to prevent lower-back pain. [1]Bolton, Roman, et al. Sleep Science and Practice. May 10, 2022. Effects of Mattress Support on Sleeping Position and Low-Back Pain. Found on the internet at https://sleep.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s41606-022-00073-x

Combination sleepers, or those who move around to different sleeping positions, should also find solid support based on the mattress’s versatility and high responsiveness, making repositioning easier.

Our expert take

First, we want to note that the Saatva Classic is a made-to-order hybrid mattress with layers of memory foam and steel pocket coils. Saatva mattresses come with a 365-night trial period and a lifetime limited warranty. The Classic mattress is made with eco-friendly materials and has several height and firmness choices to help sleepers find the right fit for their needs.

You can choose from plush soft (3 out of 10 based on our firmness ratings), luxury firm (5 to 7 out of 10), and firm (8 out of 10). You can also choose between two mattress heights: 11.5 inches and 14.5 inches.

After resting on the mattress, we appreciated that Saatva has a classic innerspring feel. It’s bouncy and responsive, but the tufted pillow top offers plush cushioning. We didn’t sink too far into the layers when we spread out on the mattress. It felt like we were sleeping ‘on top of’ the mattress rather than ‘inside.’

We also liked that the Saatva Classic mattress comes with free white glove delivery and setup, especially since the queen mattresses weigh more than 100 pounds. The company contacts you to schedule a delivery date and time after you place your order. The brand’s white glove delivery service also includes the removal of your old mattress and box spring.

Our recommendation

Who will love it

  • Back sleepers will appreciate the spinal support in the luxury firm model in particular.
  • Combination sleepers will appreciate the zoned construction, which should feel comfortable in multiple positions.

Who should avoid it

  • Lightweight side sleepers might not sink into the comfort layers enough for sufficient cushioning around the hips and shoulders.
  • Sleepers who prefer soft mattresses will likely find even the plush soft model too firm.

Customer reviews

Saatva is well-rated on the third-party review sites we consulted. When this article was updated, the Classic was rated 4.6 out of 5 stars with more than 1,100 reviews on Trustpilot. Saatva is BBB-accredited with an A+ grade and 4.79 out of 5 stars from an average of more than 1,700 reviews.

Customer service

You can contact Saatva customer service by:

We tried the live chat feature and connected to a customer service agent right away. They resolved our question within two minutes. If you want to return your mattress within the 365-night trial window, there is a $99 processing fee that covers the pickup of your return.

Payment options

Payment options include Visa, MasterCard, Discover, American Express, Google Pay, and PayPal. Saatva offers financing options through Affirm.

Note that Saatva offers additional deals to groups such as adults 65 and older, military members, health care professionals, and more.

Best for Heavy Sleepers: Emma Hybrid Comfort Mattress

Best for Heavy Sleepers
8.6 Very Good
Discount: Save up to 50%
8.6 Very Good
Features
  • Price: $812–$1,649
  • Material: Hybrid
  • Firmness: Firm
  • Trial period: 365 nights
  • Shipping: Free shipping
  • Warranty: 10 years
  • Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king
  • Mattress height: 13″
Pros & Cons
Pros Supportive enough for people weighing more than 300 pounds A good trial period of 365 nights Cons Lightweight sleepers may find it to be too firm Lacks comfortable contouring
Additional Information

The Emma Hybrid Comfort is an affordable mattress with a firm feel that’s well suited to heavier sleepers, with minimal bounce and contouring. It’s also a good option for hot sleepers: The cover and memory foam layers are designed to stay cool as you sleep, and the coil layer also promotes airflow.

Our expert take

The Emma Hybrid Comfort is a firm mattress made with multiple layers of dense, CertiPur-US-certified foam and ultra-supportive coils. The layers are designed to dissipate heat and promote airflow to keep sleepers cooler and more comfortable. While it’s not specifically designed for heavier people, our Reviews Team found the firmer feel of the Hybrid Comfort is ideal for supporting added weight without becoming uncomfortably hot.

We also appreciated that the mattress is responsive, so it works well for sleepers who change position at night. The coils provide a good deal of bounce, and the top foam layers pop back into place quickly. During testing, we had no issues moving around or changing positions on it.

The Hybrid Comfort comes with a removable and washable cover, another uncommon feature we liked. Like other mattresses on our list, the Emma Hybrid Comfort has a 365-night trial period.

Our recommendation

Who will love it

  • Heavier sleepers who find other mattresses lack support may benefit from the support this one offers.
  • Fans of very firm mattresses may appreciate the denseness.
  • Hot sleepers may appreciate the cooling upgrades.

Who should avoid it

  • Side sleepers may find this firm mattress doesn’t offer pressure relief.
  • Those under 130 pounds who need a softer option.

Customer reviews

Reviews were limited on the third-party review sites we consulted. At Trustpilot, Emma Mattress has just ten reviews and a 2.0 rating out of 5 stars. On BBB, there are just two reviews with 1 out of 5 stars. On Google, the mattress has 3.8 out of 5 stars with 30 reviews.

Customer service

You can reach Emma customer service by:

  • Phone: Call 855-580-3662, available Monday through Friday from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. GMT
  • Email: support@emma-sleep.com
  • Chat: Live chat is available Monday through Friday from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. GMT

If you don’t like your Emma Hybrid mattress, you can call the brand’s customer service for an easy return. Emma will send a team to pick up your mattress, and you can expect a full refund within two weeks.

Payment options

Emma accepts credit card payments from American Express, MasterCard, Visa, Discover, PayPal, Google Pay, Meta Pay, Apple Pay, and Zip Pay. You can also finance through Klarna.

Best Pillow-Top: WinkBed

Best Pillow-Top Mattress
9.4 Excellent
Discount: Save $300 on your mattress
9.4 Excellent
Features
  • Price: $1,149–$2,199
  • Material: Hybrid
  • Firmness: Softer, luxury firm, firmer, plus
  • Trial period: 120 nights
  • Shipping: Free shipping
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king
  • Mattress height: 13.5″
Pros & Cons
Pros Choice of firmness 120-night trial and lifetime warranty Responsive, cooling, and supportive Cons Pricey investment Trial window isn’t as generous as some others on our list
Additional Information

The WinkBed is a classic hybrid that comes with a choice of four firmness levels, including a plus model for larger sleepers. Full edge support, cooling upgrades, and a plush Euro top make it a good choice for a variety of sleepers.

Our expert take

The WinkBed is a hybrid mattress designed for temperature regulation, strong edge support, and a responsive feel. A Euro pillowtop made with gel-infused foam offers cushioning and support, while the Tencel cover (a natural performance fabric derived from eucalyptus) helps absorb moisture and stays cooler and dry. It comes in four firmness options: soft (4 out of 10), luxury firm (6 out of 10), firmer (7.5 out of 10) and firm (8 out of 10). That makes it a versatile option for different kinds of sleepers.

Our Reviews Team member tested this mattress by sleeping on their back, during which we felt a pleasant balance of comfort and support. We also noticed its zoning offers great lumbar support. The main support comes from a layer of individually wrapped coils, which are zoned for more stability in the center of the mattress. They also contribute to the bouncy, responsive feel of the mattress. That’s a great feature for combination sleepers, but it might not be ideal for couples who are easily disturbed by movement during sleep.

Our recommendation

Who will love it

  • Hot sleepers may benefit from the cooling materials and hybrid construction.
  • Sleepers who routinely wake up with back pain may appreciate the support this mattress gives.

Who should avoid it

  • Shoppers on a budget may find this mattress too expensive.
  • Couples might find it doesn’t sufficiently isolate motion.

Customer reviews

On Trustpilot, 101 reviews give the company 3.7 out of 5 stars. WinkBeds is not BBB accredited, but it has a B rating and 4.11 stars based on 174 customer reviews. On Google, WinkBeds has 4.6 out of 5 stars and more than 17,000 reviews.

Customer service

You can reach WinkBeds customer service by:

  • Phone: Call 855-946-5233, Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 7 p.m. ET
  • Email: info@winkbeds.com
  • Live chat

WinkBeds requests that customers test the mattress for at least 30 days before issuing a return before the 120-night trial period, because it often takes a few weeks to get used to a new bed. 

Payment options

Credit card payment options include  MasterCard, Visa, American Express, Discover, Shop Pay, Google Pay, and Apple Pay. WinkBeds offers financing through Bread Pay.

Best Pressure Relief: Nolah Evolution

Best Pressure Relief
9.4 Excellent
Discount: 35% off sitewide
9.4 Excellent
Features
  • Price: $1,499–$3,198
  • Material: Hybrid
  • Firmness: Plush, luxury firm, firm
  • Trial period: 120 nights
  • Shipping: Free shipping
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king, split king
  • Mattress height: 15″
Pros & Cons
Pros Multiple cooling features 120-night trial and lifetime warranty Cons Expensive investment Not many third-party reviews available
Additional Information

The Nolah Evolution is a high-end hybrid mattress with superior cooling, comfort, and support. The mattress is designed to accommodate different body types and sleep positions, giving you the option of choosing between three firmness levels.

Our expert take

The Nolah Evolution is a luxury hybrid mattress that measures 15 inches in height. It’s made with multiple layers of cooling and supportive foams, as well as a zoned coil layer for pressure relief and durability. The quilted Euro topper is designed with a breathable gusset that helps dissipate excess body heat, while graphite-infused foam at the core of the mattress actively cools by drawing away heat. Zoned support in the coil layer of the Evolution gives it a firmer feel toward the center, which is ideal for back sleepers.

In our testing, we found the combination of these layers gives the mattress a nice balance of comfort and support. When combined with its bouncy eco-support coils, the plush pillow top creates a balanced hybrid feel that’s easy to move around on. We think most sleepers won’t feel like they’re sinking too far into the mattress when they rest on it.

Like others on our list, the Nolah Evolution is a bed-in-a-box mattress that ships free anywhere in the contiguous United States. Each mattress is made to order and shipped via FedEx Ground, so it should arrive four to eight business days after you place your order on the Nolah website. White-glove delivery is available through a third-party vendor called Load Up and costs an additional $300 for removal and setup or $150 if you choose to use only one of the services.

Our recommendation

Who will love it

  • Hot sleepers may benefit from the graphite-infused foam and airflow-promoting coils.
  • Back sleepers will appreciate the enhanced lumbar support.

Who should avoid it

  • Shoppers on a budget may want to look at other options.
  • Stomach sleepers might find the firmest option supportive but not soft enough.

Customer reviews

Reviews on third-party platforms are hard to find, with minimal reviews on Trustpilot and BBB. Nolah has 2.8 out of 5 stars on Trustpilot and 2.5 out of 5 stars on BBB, both from only three reviews on each site. While Nolah isn’t BBB accredited, it does have an A+ rating, which means that the company responds to customer complaints. On Google, the Nolah Evolution has 4.7 out of 5 stars with more than 600 reviews.

Customer service

You can reach Nolah customer service by:

  • Phone: Call 866-403-6615, available Monday through Friday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. CST
  • Email: support@nolahmattress.com
  • Chat: Live chat available Monday through Friday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. CST

Since it can take a few weeks to break in a new mattress, Nolah asks its customers to try out their bed for 30 days before returning it. After the 30-day window, returns are accepted for a full refund during the 120-night sleep trial period.

Payment options

Nolah accepts MasterCard, Visa, American Express, Discover, Shop Pay, and PayPal. Financing is available through Affirm.

Best Mattress for Back Sleepers: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

Best Mattress for Back Sleepers
9.3 Excellent
Discount: 25% off sitewide
9.3 Excellent
Features
  • Price: $665–$1,599
  • Material: Hybrid
  • Firmness: Soft, medium, firm
  • Trial period: 120 nights
  • Shipping: Free shipping
  • Warranty: 10 years
  • Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, short full, queen, short queen, Olympic queen, king, short king, RV king, California king
  • Mattress height: 12.25″
Pros & Cons
Pros Budget-friendly Choice of firmness levels for more customization Multiple foam comfort layers Cons 10-year limited warranty Optional pillow-top is an extra expense
Additional Information

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid mattress is a high-quality mattress with a budget-friendly price tag. It’s sold in multiple firmness options to accommodate different body types and sleep styles. We find it a particularly great option for combination sleepers, back sleepers, and couples.

Our expert take

The Signature Hybrid from Brooklyn Bedding is a responsive hybrid mattress with a number of upgrades for the price. That includes a quilted top with moisture-wicking properties, quick-moving memory foam that adjusts as you move, and individually wrapped coils to contour closely to your body, help isolate motion, and offer edge-to-edge support. Brooklyn Bedding owns its own factory, so the company can keep prices down by eliminating middleman costs.

Brooklyn Bedding has loaded their mattress with premium materials and features. Individually wrapped coils offer support and a springy, responsive surface. Luxurious foam layers add comfort and promote cooling. Additionally, there are three firmness options, so you can customize the mattress to fit your unique sleeping position.

You can add additional comfort layers for more contouring and pressure point relief with the optional pillow-top upgrade. It’s made with cooling fibers to minimize overheating.

Our recommendation

Who will love it

  • Those looking for a solid deal on a mattress with good quality.
  • Side, back, and combination sleepers.

Who should avoid it

  • Those who don’t enjoy the feel of an innerspring, since this feels similar.
  • Sleepers who prefer close contouring may not like the memory foam components.

Customer reviews

On Trustpilot, there are 36 reviews and a 2 out of 5 star rating. Many of the negative reviews are for a dog bed that isn’t sold by the company. Brooklyn Bedding has been accredited on BBB since 2021 and has an A+ rating. The brand has 31 reviews with a 1.94 rating out of five stars.

Customer service

You can reach Brooklyn Bedding customer service by:

  • Phone: Call 623-624-1222, Monday through Friday, 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. ET and weekends, 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. ET
  • Email: support@brooklynbedding.com
  • Live chat
  • Submitting a contact form on the website

You’ll have 120 nights to try out the mattress, but this trial period may only be used once per customer per calendar year. If it’s not a good fit, you can arrange an exchange or a no-fees return during the 120-night trial. Like other mattress companies, Brooklyn Bedding requires that customers wait 30 days before initiating a return. Note that in Hawaii, Alaska, and Canada, shipping fees are non-refundable.

Payment options

Accepted credit card payments include: MasterCard, Visa, American Express, Discover, Amazon Pay, and PayPal. Financing through Brooklyn Bedding is available through Affirm.

Best Plush Mattress: Puffy Lux Hybrid

Best Plush Mattress
9.1 Excellent
Discount: Save up to $2,700
9.1 Excellent
Features
  • Price: $2,249–$4,798
  • Material: Hybrid
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Trial period: 101 nights
  • Shipping: Free shipping
  • Warranty: Limited lifetime warranty
  • Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king, split king
  • Mattress height: 12″
Pros & Cons
Pros Three layers of foam for pressure relief Washable top cover Limited lifetime warranty Cons No in-home delivery available Not many third-party reviews available
Additional Information

The Puffy Lux mattress could be a worthwhile investment for people in search of a mattress with a luxurious feel, excellent pressure relief, and close contouring, or the feeling of the mattress hugging you. Its combination of soft foam layers and individually pocketed coils makes it a good choice for side and back sleepers.

Our expert take

Plush mattresses have layers of soft material on top and supportive layers below, which work together to create a feeling of softness without that “sinking in” feeling of some ultra-soft mattresses. The Puffy Lux Hybrid Mattress has three layers of CertiPUR-US certified foams and a layer of pocketed coils that create a medium-plush feel that falls around a 5 to 7 out of 10 on our firmness scale.

When lying on the bed, we noticed that even though the mattress has springs at the bottom, the comfort layers feel especially slow-moving. This makes the Lux Hybrid a fantastic choice for people who prefer softer beds but still want support.

Our Reviews Team also liked that its firmness range offers support and pressure relief. That makes it a good choice for side and back sleepers. The Lux Hybrid mattress also has a washable top cover, whereas most are not removable.

Puffy mattresses get compressed and rolled into a box for delivery. The company recommends having some help unboxing the mattress and removing the packaging. It needs to expand to its full height for up to two hours before you use it.

Our recommendation

Who will love it

  • Fans of soft mattresses.
  • Back sleepers will appreciate the contouring support in the lower back area.
  • Side sleepers, who will appreciate the pressure relief at the joints.

Who should avoid it

  • Stomach sleepers might find it’s too soft for proper hip support.
  • Combination sleepers might find it’s not bouncy enough to change positions easily.

Customer reviews

We couldn’t find many third-party reviews. When we updated this article, Puffy had 3.3 out of 5 stars on Trustpilot with 97 reviews. Puffy isn’t accredited on BBB and has a D-, but has 4.08 out of 5 stars from an average of 51 customer reviews. On Google, the mattress has 4.9 out of 5 stars with more than 6,000 reviews.

Customer service

You can reach Puffy customer service by:

  • Phone: Call 800-430-8380, available Monday through Friday, 5 a.m. to 8 p.m. PT and weekends from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. PT
  • Email: support@puffy.com
  • Chat: Live chat on the bottom right corner of the website, available Monday through Friday, 5 a.m. to 8 p.m. PT and weekends from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. PT
  • Submitting a contact form on its website

Unlike other brands that ask customers to try out their mattresses for at least 30 nights, Puffy only has a 14-night minimum trial period, though 30 days is still recommended. Then you’ll have the opportunity to return it within the 101-night trial. The company will arrange the pickup of your mattress and donate it to a children’s charity.

A lifetime limited warranty also covers you for the rest of the time you own the mattress.

Payment options

The brand accepts the following credit cards: Discover, Visa, MasterCard, American Express, and PayPal. Puffy offers financing through Klarna.

Best Smart Mattress: Saatva Solaire

Best Smart Mattress
9.7 Exceptional
Discount: Save up to $500
9.7 Exceptional
Features
  • Price: $3,295–$6,590
  • Material: Air chamber
  • Firmness: Adjustable
  • Trial period: 365 nights
  • Shipping: Free shipping with free in-room delivery and setup
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • Sizes: Twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king, split California king, upper-flex queen, upper-flex king
  • Mattress height: 13″
Pros & Cons
Pros 50 firmness settings Customizable firmness on both sides (for queen or larger only) Free in-room delivery and setup 365-night home trial and lifetime warranty Cons Pricey investment $99 return fee
Additional Information

The Saatva Solaire is made for sleepers who want customizable firmness to suit their specific sleep needs, which makes it an excellent choice for couples who don’t agree on what’s comfortable. The air bed has 50 unique firmness settings, along with layers of latex and memory foam for pressure relief.

Our expert take

While Saatva is known for its high-quality and durable mattresses, the Solaire is its most luxurious option due to its smart features and ultra-adjustability. Vulcanized air bed chambers make it possible to choose from 50 different firmness levels. For queen-size mattresses and larger, the firmness level is adjustable on both sides of the bed, which means no compromising for couples. These settings range from a medium to a firm feel.

Positioned above the air chambers are support and comfort layers designed to relieve pressure, enhance lumbar support, and help disperse body heat for cooler sleep. When lying on the mattress, you’ll notice it has a pillow-top feel with a bit of memory foam softness beneath that. The top few layers also have some latex, which adds a bit of bounce, so it shouldn’t be difficult to move around on the mattress or switch positions at night.

Unlike many adjustable mattresses, the air inflator on the Solaire is built into the front of the mattress. You can adjust firmness levels with remote controls for each side of the bed.

Our recommendation

Who will love it

  • Couples may appreciate the ability to customize their respective firmness level preferences on queen beds or larger.
  • Hot sleepers may appreciate the dispersion of body heat.
  • Combination sleepers will like the easy ability to move around.

Who should avoid it

  • Shoppers on a budget may want to look for other options.
  • Those who prefer soft mattresses may not like this level of firmness.

Customer reviews

Saatva has excellent reviews online. The company is highly rated on Trustpilot, with a 4.6 rating out of 1,159 reviews. Saatva has been accredited on the BBB since 2011 and currently has an A+ rating, with 4.79 stars based on 1,741 reviews.

Customer service

You can reach Saatva customer service by:

  • Phone: Call 877-672-2882, available 24/7
  • Email: info@saatvamattress.com
  • Live chat

Customers can return their Saatva Solaire for a full refund during the 365-night sleep trial period, but a $99 transportation fee is applied to all returns.

Payment options

Saatva accepts major credit cards, like MasterCard, Visa, American Express, and Discover, as well as Google Pay, and PayPal. Financing for Saatva mattresses is available through Affirm.

Cost comparison of the best mattresses, as of February 2024

MattressTwin*Full*Queen*King*
Helix Midnight Luxe$1,373.80 $1,998.80 $2,373.80$2,873.80
Nectar Premier$1,049 $1,349 $1,499 $1,799
Saatva Classic$1,295$1,895 $1,995 $2,495
Emma Hybrid Comfort Mattress$739$1,049$1,199 $1,499
WinkBeds$1,149 $1,499 $1,799 $1,999
Nolah Evolution$1,499 $2,299 $2,499 $2,699
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid$665 $999$1,332 $1,599
Puffy Lux Hybrid$2,249 $2,649 $2,849 $3,049
Saatva Solaire$3,295 $4,095 $4,495 $5,295
* Cost of mattress excluding promotions, discounts, and shipping charges

How to pick the best mattress for you

Choosing the best mattress is a personal decision that should be considered carefully based on a number of factors.

Sleeping position considerations

How you sleep can dictate what you should prioritize or avoid in a mattress and help prevent pain. [3]Radwan, Ahmed, et al. Sleep Health. December 2015. Effect of Different Mattress Designs on Promoting Sleep Quality, Pain Reduction, and Spinal Alignment in Adults With or Without Back Pain; Systematic Review of Controlled Trials. Found on the internet at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352721815001400 Side sleepers can benefit from a softer mattress designed to provide pressure relief and cradle the hips and shoulders. Stomach sleepers often experience pressure on the lower back, so a firmer mattress is important to support the hips for proper spinal alignment. Back sleepers also need to maintain a neutral spine to avoid aches and pains in the morning. Those who switch positions throughout the night are known as combination sleepers. A mattress that’s responsive enough to support movement can make that easier.

Firmness

A mattress firmness scale showing one is the softest and 10 is the firmest
Our testers rate the firmness of mattresses on a scale of 1–10, with 1 being the softest and 10 being the firmest.

The firmness of a mattress, also called the “comfort level” or “feel,” is a subjective rating between soft and firm. Firmness can also be graded on a scale of one to 10, with one the softest and 10 the most firm. Systematic reviews of studies have suggested that mattresses subjectively labeled “medium firm” are the best for promoting sleep quality and comfort. [3]Radwan, Ahmed, et al. Sleep Health. December 2015. Effect of Different Mattress Designs on Promoting Sleep Quality, Pain Reduction, and Spinal Alignment in Adults With or Without Back Pain; Systematic Review of Controlled Trials. Found on the internet at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352721815001400

Mattress construction types

Composition of foam, latex, innerspring, hybrid, and air adjustable mattresses
There are five different types of mattresses, each made of a combination of different materials, like latex foam, steel coils, and air-filled chambers.

You have many choices when it comes to mattresses. Each type is made of different materials offering various support and comfort levels.

Pain management and relief

Medium-firm mattresses tend to be the best option for relieving or helping to prevent back pain, hip pain, and shoulder pain. [3]Radwan, Ahmed, et al. Sleep Health. December 2015. Effect of Different Mattress Designs on Promoting Sleep Quality, Pain Reduction, and Spinal Alignment in Adults With or Without Back Pain; Systematic Review of Controlled Trials. Found on the internet at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352721815001400 Material choice can play a role too. Those living with back pain can benefit from a balance of comfort and support, which makes a hybrid or innerspring design a good option. For shoulder and hip pain, contouring and pressure relief is key. You’ll find that more with memory foam and latex mattresses.

Temperature control features

If you sleep hot or share a bed with a partner who sleeps hot, you may want to consider buying a mattress with cooling features. Temperature regulation can come with breathable natural or synthetic fiber covers, gel foam layers, perforated layers, and materials with PCMs, or phase change materials, which are designed to absorb body heat. [4]Priego Quesada, Jose I., et al. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science. February 2017. Assessment of a Mattress With Phase Change Materials Using a Thermal and Perception Test. Found on the internet at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0894177716302941

Body type and weight considerations

It’s important to factor in your body type and weight when you choose a mattress. Heavier bodies (which we consider more than 230 pounds) will compress mattress materials more than lighter bodies due to gravity, so firmer mattresses tend to be a better choice. Lightweight sleepers (which we consider those less than 130 pounds) should consider softer mattresses, so that they sink in enough to benefit from the comfort layers on top.

Sleeping position can play a role, too. For example, side sleepers in higher weight ranges should consider something in the medium-firm range to ensure sufficient cushioning around the hips and shoulders.

Sleeping next to a partner or pets

Sharing a mattress means considering more than one person’s sleep preferences, like sleeping temperatures, firmness preferences, or areas for support. Memory foam mattresses tend to transfer motion less than innerspring mattresses, so they may be a good option for those with partners sensitive to bed movement.

Where is the best place to purchase a mattress?

Once you have reviewed the best types of mattresses above and settled on one that suits you, you’ll need to decide where to purchase your new bed.

In-store vs. buying online

While you can find an excellent mattress both in a traditional store and by buying online, you should consider what’s most important to you as a shopper. For the best value, wallet-friendly prices, and widest selection, you’ll want to look online. If you prefer to test out a mattress in person before making a purchase, and you like the attention of a salesperson who can answer all of your questions, you may have a better experience in a local store. Some online mattress companies also have in-person showrooms for testing.

Mattress store vs. direct from the brand

You may want to purchase your new mattress from a brick-and-mortar store so you can see it in person and get a feel for the bed. Your first option is a dedicated mattress store that stocks several different mattress brands. While this offers the opportunity to browse and compare various mattresses from different companies at the same time, the store may not carry every model or size. Additionally, a mattress store may offer promotions and sales but still not give you the best deal compared to purchasing directly from the company. The return policy and warranty terms may differ as well. 

Your other option is to purchase your mattress directly from the brand. While some brands still have physical retail stores you can visit to try out a mattress, others operate solely online. If you aren’t able to try it out in person, buying from a company that offers a fair sleep trial of 30 days or more is your best protection against being stuck with a mattress you’re unhappy with. You may also find that you can get the best deal when purchasing your mattress directly from the mattress company during online sales or promotions, vs. a mattress store that has more overhead costs and fewer sales.

Bottom line

Ultimately, weighing factors like cost, firmness levels, trial periods, and the type of sleeper you are will be critical when shopping for a mattress. While the Saatva Classic is our top pick, followed by the Helix Midnight Luxe and Puffy Luxe Hybrid, which we’ve found cater to most types of sleepers, all the mattresses on this list have been tested by our Reviews Team, so you can make an informed decision about which one is right for you.

Frequently asked questions

The type of mattress that’s best for you depends on your individual sleeping needs. For example, it may depend on your sleeping position, body type, preferred firmness level, and sleeping temperature. You may also take into account your partner’s sleeping preferences.

Our Reviews Team spent hundreds of hours researching and analyzing to recommend the best mattresses. While our mattress recommendations vary depending on individual needs and preferences, we found the Saatva Classic mattress, Helix Midnight Lux, and Puffy Lux Hybrid mattresses work the best for most sleepers.

Most people who live with back pain will find relief with a firm or medium-firm mattress. This type of bed helps maintain spinal alignment overnight, which can help alleviate or prevent pain. A balance of comfort and support is also important, so hybrid constructions tend to be a good option.

Experts recommend you replace your mattress every seven to 10 years. Many bedding brands have huge sales around federal holidays, so you might want to time your shopping around President’s Day, Memorial Day, and even Labor Day. You’ll also find great deals around Black Friday and Cyber Monday.

Brands usually post reviews and ratings on their websites, but you can also browse Better Business Bureau (BBB), Trustpilot, and Google to see which mattress has the highest customer satisfaction. Keep in mind that not all of these ratings carry over from one review platform to the other.

Based on our research, some of the best all-around customer satisfaction rates are associated with Saatva, WinkBeds, and Nolah. Helix and Puffy also earn high marks on Google, but not as high on BBB or Trustpilot.

Mattress warranties vary by company. Generally, a mattress warranty ensures your bed functions as advertised and protects against defects caused by the manufacturer. Some warranties only last for a set amount of years, while others are advertised as “lifetime” warranties. But even lifetime warranties have limitations. When shopping for a new mattress, make sure to carefully review the terms of each company’s warranty and trial period, both of which should play an important role in your purchase decision.

Have questions about this review? Email us at reviewsteam@ncoa.org.

Sources

  1. Bolton, Roman, et al. Effects of Mattress Support on Sleeping Position and Low-Back Pain. Sleep Science and Practice. May 10, 2022. Found on the internet at https://sleep.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s41606-022-00073-x
  2. Baniassadi, Amir, et al. Nighttime Ambient Temperature and Sleep in Community-Dwelling Older Adults. Science of the Total Environment. Nov. 15, 2023. Found on the internet at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0048969723042468
  3. Bolton, Roman. Effects of Mattress Support on Sleeping Position and Low-Back Pain. Sleep Science and Practice. May 10, 2022. Found on the internet at https://sleep.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s41606-022-00073-x
  4. Priego Quesada, Jose I., et al. Assessment of a Mattress With Phase Change Materials Using a Thermal and Perception Test. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science. February 2017. Found on the internet at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0894177716302941
Marten has been writing about mattresses and sleep health for over five years. He is the Lead Reviewer at Mattress Clarity where he reviews mattresses, bedding, and sleep accessories. In his time at Mattress Clarity, Marten has reviewed over 500 mattresses. In addition, he has written over 400 articles reviewing the quality of sleep and sleep products as well as sleep health. Topics have ranged from the impact of technology on sleep quality to the way sleep impacts cardiovascular health. He is especially interested in the correlation between proper sleep and mental health.
dr-raj-dasgupta
Raj Dasgupta Medical Reviewer
Dr. Raj Dasgupta brings his deep experience and compassion to our medical advisory board as Mattress Clarity’s Chief Medical Advisor. He’s an ABIM quadruple board-certified physician specializing in internal medicine, pulmonology, critical care, and sleep medicine. Dr. Raj is also a fellow of the American College of Physicians (FACP), the American College of Chest Physicians (FCCP), and the American College of American Academy of Sleep Medicine (FAASM). In addition to his clinical work and research, Dr. Raj currently practices at the University of Southern California and serves as associate professor of clinical medicine, the associate program director of the sleep medicine fellowship at USC, and assistant program director of the internal medicine residency program. From his work at USC, he’s been awarded the Excellence in Teaching award six years in a row.
Was this helpful?
Thank you for your feedback!